L. camphoratus | L. rubidus | L. fragilis | |
Pileus shape | papilla sometimes present at disc | papilla or umbo typically not present | umbo sometimes present at disc |
Color | darker reddish-brown | more deep reddish-brown ("ferruginous") | lighter reddish-brown to light brown |
Lamellae | more light yellowish to light orange | more light reddish | more light reddish |
Spores | ellipsoid to subglobose; 7.0–8.5 x 6.0–7.5 µm; ornamentation not connected (spines to short ridges) | subglobose to globose; 6.0–8.5 x 6.0–8.0 µm; ornamentation semi-connected (broken to partial reticulum) | subglobose to globose; 6.0–7.5 x 6.0–7.5 µm; ornamentation connected (partial to complete reticulum) |
Odor | more curry-like | more maple-like; strong only upon drying | more maple-like; strong, even when fresh |
Distribution | Europe, Asia, eastern North America | western North America; also reported from Costa Rica | eastern North America |
the latex of L. rubidus here in CA does change upon exposure to air ...
from a pale milky liquid to almost clear. It is quite possible that you don't have
the exact same species up in the PNW. Our CA rubidus in the Bay Area occur more frequently
under pine;
rufulus, which is much more reddish and stocky in appearance, occurs under oak.
--------------------------------------------------------------
Patrick H. said
What I started doing (in addition to discussing those points) is to bring a baggie with fenugreek in it to show folks that smell.
It isn't enough to say it smells like "curry" (as some guides do) or "vaguely spicy" but actually taking a whiff of fenugreek--a main ingredient in most Indian curry powders--brings it all back home. Sort of.
I also describe the smell as "burnt caramel" but without the burnt taste.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mike said
If the latex is thin and resembles skim milk, the smell is sweet, the flesh is sweet and mushroomy, or at least not acrid, and the cap is rough, then it's a candy cap.
If the latex is thick or bright white, or white changing from white to yellow, or just yellow then it's not. If it's acrid, or even slightly acrid, it's not. If the cap is smooth it's not. If it lacks a sweet or fenugreeky smell then it may not be.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On Yahoo Mushroom talk 1/27/17 by "doublegregg"
I've been gathering candy caps for a few years, and can't exactly remember coming upon
another Lactarius that looks, to my middling eye, almost exactly like a 'candy cap.'
I've never been sure of the exact naming of the two (?) types of candy caps that
are available in the bay area.
One seems to prefer pines, and the other oaks. I prefer the piney candy cap, which is much lighter in color and more fragrant.... The mushrooms i'm trying to id here look very much like this candy cap
Here are some photos from my phone (see above).
The mushrooms have light colored gills, slightly darker colored stems,
which are kind of stout and not holloiw... Everything about them looks similar
to a candy cap.
The only way I can tell them apart is a) the latex is white, and doesn't change in color b) there's no nice candy cap odor. And, yeah, I guess the stems in this mushroom seem just slighly stouter and meatier... clumps of them reveal the spores to be white.
I tried tasting a bit of cap, in case it was L rufus. I couldn't tell if it was hot. Sounds like L rufus is VERY hot?? I ruled out L rufus. L substriatus has white milk which turns yellow, as does L xanthogalactus.... L subflammeus?? or something similar?
I'm not even sure I should be concerned with identifying it, other than some 'other'
Lactarius... however, I guess i'd hate to mistake it for a candy cap and eat
it..................
I'm open to suggestions - mainly,
I want to gather my candy caps safely - it would be nice to know exactly what the
other look-a-likes are. I have to admit this one has me concerned because it is SO similar.
Thank you!
. to me they're almost identical to candy caps.......... jeezus...... in the
previous photos one can see what sort of trees they were growing under
(some sort of pine thing.... long needles....)
------------------------------------